Skip to main content

Bordering on Inhumanity: Trump’s Policy of Forcibly Separating Migrant Families Deliberately Causing Trauma to Children

By Kim Belshé, Executive Director, First 5 LA

In recent weeks, the Trump administration’s new border crossing policy has separated more than 2,000 children from their migrant parents.

Heart-wrenching photographs of small children in cages at federal processing facilities and reports of parents separated from their children at the southern border, including one father from Honduras who killed himself after his wife and son were taken from him, have dominated mainstream news.

At First 5 LA, we believe in staying true to our mission and values, and speaking truth to power. The Trump Administration’s practice of forcibly separating children from their parents is immoral and unacceptable. It doesn’t matter if you’re in Los Angeles, California or McAllen, Texas. We stand firmly against any policy that deliberately causes trauma to children. We stand firmly against any policy that intentionally uses children as political pawns.

As experts in child development, we know that when our government separates children from their parents at the border our government is causing toxic stress — intense, repetitive or prolonged adversity without an adult’s positive intervention. Toxic stress can usually be seen when a child survives a natural disaster or lives in deep poverty, a war zone or a refugee camp. Instead, the disaster these children are facing is entirely man made.

Where children are separated from their parents for a long period of time, they remain on high alert, and their bodies endure prolonged and severe toxic stress as a result. That interrupts the brain’s architecture at a critical time of development.

Experts emphasize that the long-term toll of toxic stress is both physical and mental. Children separated from their parents are more likely to experience behavioral problems, drop out of school, and struggle with substance abuse or be diagnosed with chronic illnesses, such as diabetes or heart disease.

Children currently in detention facilities eventually are placed in a shelter or with a sponsor while they navigate immigration court proceedings. At the same time, they are struggling with multiple levels of separation. The initial trauma of being separated from their parent or guardian is compounded by further trauma of the days, weeks and months without their parent. In the meantime, those children have none of the familiar surroundings of their prior home; many struggle with even being able to communicate in a new language and wonder whether they will ever see their parent again.

While the Trump Administration continues to defend the separation of children and parents at the border, Congress is considering several immigration proposals, some of which address family separation. But it’s not clear how much support the proposals will receive, even in the face of growing public backlash.

Tasked directly by voters to urge leaders and lawmakers to prioritize the wellbeing of children, First 5 LA is deeply concerned and stands alongside child advocacy and human rights organizations. Recently, First 5 LA joined 540 organizations across the country in signing the Renewed Appeal from Experts in Child Welfare, Juvenile Justice and Child Development to Halt the Separation of Children from Parents at the Border letter urging the Secretary of U.S. Department of Homeland Security to abandon current policies and practices that systematically separate immigrant children from their families.

While this version of the border crossing policy has since been rescinded by an Executive Order signed by the President, the effects of this deliberately imposed trauma on children and their families separated at the border may last a lifetime.

Despite this being an ever-evolving situation, our long-term goal as an organization is to provide information and perspective to help decision makers and leading stakeholders make better, more informed decisions. As advocates for kids, we see our role as highlighting the impact every policy has on children.

Newcomers to America push our economy forward with their skills and ideas. We need policies to harness that energy for our nation to help build a stronger economy and a brighter future for kids and adults alike. Our immigration regulations at every level should reflect the deep American belief that people are people, and deserve to be treated with dignity and respect.

We will continue to urge leaders and lawmakers to make budget and policy decisions that prioritize young children.

More in Articles

Home Visiting: Tales, Triumphs and Trailblazing
Tiffany’s first child passed away only days after being born. Not long afterward, she discovered she was pregnant. Six months later her son...

Parents Put Research into Action to Improve Quality Time with Kids
When Natasha Guerrero began surveying other parents in her community last year, she was surprised to learn how little quality time they were spending...

Making the News: Home Visiting
Editor’s Note: "Can you find me that one article from a few months ago…” was a common question here at First 5 LA, so we...

More in Press release

Proposed Change to “Public Charge” Policy Hurts Kids, Say Leading California Early Childhood Advocates
First 5s, Created to Help Kids, Call for Policy to Remain Unchanged, Urge Administration and Lawmakers to Work Collaboratively to Create Long-lasting...

Progress Made for California’s Children and Families in State Budget
Stage Set for Future Leaders to Deepen Commitment to Investments in Home Visiting, Early Care & Education LOS ANGELES – Today, the...

Parents and Communities Create New Local Leadership for First 5 LA Place-based Effort
New, Regional Structure of Best Start Communities Intended to Help Amplify Voices for Young KidsLOS ANGELES – Acting on broad...

More in Press room

Governor Brown Urged to Build Legacy as a Champion for California’s Youngest Children
Download this press release »First 5 LA Urges Billion Dollar Investment in Early Learning for Infants and Toddlers Backs Gov. Brown...

Lawmakers Urged to Recognize Importance of Young Children at First 5 Advocacy Day 2018
Capitol Lawn Event Marks 20th Anniversary of Voters' Approval of Prop 10 that Created First 5 Network, Honors Several State Legislators as "...

First 5 LA Applauds Governor Brown For Prioritizing California’s Youngest Children and Families in Proposed Budget
LOS ANGELES – Governor Jerry Brown’s proposed budget for FY 2018-19 takes a significant step forward in prioritizing children from birth...
© 2004-2018 First 5 Los Angeles

First 5 LA · 750 North Alameda Street, Suite 300 · Los Angeles, CA 90012
Phone: 213-482-5902 · Fax: 213-482-5903

Stay Informed · Privacy Policy and Terms of Use · FAQ · Contact Us · Site Map